© Getty Images

Resolution alleging to combat anti-Semitism -

The German Bundestag has approved a controversial resolution alleging to combat anti-Semitism, which has been actively opposed by civil society organizations, Jewish intellectuals, and legal experts.

© Getty Images

Definition of anti-Semitism -

Following months of closed-door negotiations, the resolution, first proposed following the October 7 attacks, ties public funds to adherence to projects that engage in the Bundestag’s definition of anti-Semitism.

© Getty Images

BDS movement -

The Bundestag issued a statement that seeks “to ensure that no organizations or projects that spread anti-Semitism, question Israel's right to exist, call for a boycott of Israel or actively support the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement receive financial support."

© Getty Images

Fear and censorship -

This measure has created a sense of fear and censorship in German society. Cultural and academic institutions fear speaking out on human rights issues pertaining to Israel’s aggressions in the Middle East.

© Getty Images

German history -

Germany’s history of anti-Semitism is certainly significant. The nation must ensure measures are in place to protect the lives and dignity of Jewish people.

© Getty Images

Allensbach Institute -

In 2022, the Allensbach Institute conducted a survey on society’s attitudes towards Jewish people and found that anti-Semitism is “deeply rooted” in mainstream German society.

© Getty Images

Far right harbors anti-Semitism -

While the recent resolution focuses on the attitudes of Germany’s Muslim communities, primarily those with pro-Palestine sentiments, according to the Allensbach Institute, the far-right movement harbors the most anti-Semitic attitudes.

© Getty Images

Alternative for Germany (AfD) -

The study found that voters of Germany’s far-right party Alternative for Germany (AfD) are more likely to hold anti-Semitic views than any other political group.

© Getty Images

Distinguishing between a religion and a state -

The survey shows that Muslim communities are, in general, able to distinguish between a religion and a state’s political behavior. Yet the Bundestag does not make that distinction.

© Getty Images

International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance -

For the German parliament, critiques of Israel from individuals, institutions, and organizations are fundamentally anti-Semitic, a contested definition of anti-Semitism issued by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA).

© Getty Images

Equating critique of Israeli government with anti-Semitism - While the IHRA working definition of anti-Semitism has been adopted by 43 countries and a few international bodies, it has been criticized for equating critique of the Israeli government with anti-Semitism.

© Getty Images

Support from some organizations -

The proposal has received support from Germany’s most prominent Jewish and Israeli organizations, such as the Central Council of Jews in Germany and the German-Israeli Society.

© Getty Images

Amnesty International Germany -

Amnesty International Germany stated that the resolution "not only fails to achieve this goal, but also raises fears of serious violations of fundamental human rights and legal uncertainty.”

© Getty Images

Reinforces censorship and division -

The organization also argues that measures like these reinforce censorship and division, rather than actively addressing the conditions producing anti-Semitism in Germany and elsewhere.

© Getty Images

The German Green Party -

The German Green Party argues that the resolution seeks to frame legitimate critiques of the Israeli government’s policies and actions as anti-Semitic, preventing discussions on violations of international law.

© Getty Images

Germany’s Social Democrats -

Germany’s Social Democrats echo the Green Party’s position, arguing that this measure is also a violation of German constitutional law.

© Getty Images

BDS as anti-Semitic -

In 2019, the Bundestag passed a non-binding resolution that described the BDS movement as anti-Semitic, yet its research service group found the content to be unconstitutional, echoed by several courts.

© Getty Images

Administrative guidance -

Yet the 2019 resolution both forms the base for the most recent measure and acts as a form of administrative guidance, as well as generates fear that results in self-censorship.

© Getty Images

Used by law enforcement -

While the legislation tied to the 2019 resolution is unlikely to become enacted in law, it is used by law enforcement entities to employ repressive measures.

© Getty Images

Freedom of expression -

Debates regarding freedom of expression in Germany have been widespread, and this resolution further contributes toward those discussions.

© Getty Images

Jewish intellectuals -

In August 2024, 150 Jewish intellectuals living in Germany issued an open letter expressing their disagreement with the German government’s conflation between criticism of Israel and anti-Semitism.

© Getty Images

Endangers lives of Jewish people -

Signatories to the letter state that reinforcing the association between Jewish people as a whole and the Israeli government not only endangers the lives of Jewish people in Germany, but is also an anti-Semitic trope.

© Getty Images

Dehumanization -

Signatories state that while mass efforts are being made to point to minorities in conflating Jewish people with the Israeli state, identifying Palestinians and their supporters as the groups responsible for anti-Semitism in the country is an act of dehumanization.

© Getty Images

German far-right movements -

Simultaneously, there is little mention of the biggest historical and contemporary threat to Jewish life in Germany: German far-right movements.

© Getty Images

Far-right tactics -

In fact, some argue that creating ideological conditions tied to the allegiance toward the state’s beliefs as a condition to receiving its support and as a basis for punishment precisely feeds into far-right tactics.

© Getty Images

Yuval Abraham -

In November 2024, Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham, co-director of ‘No Other Land,’ a film about Israel’s internationally recognized illegal occupation of the West Bank, was accused of anti-Semitism by the city of Berlin.

© Getty Images

Legal action -

Abraham, a Jewish-Israeli and descendant of Holocaust survivors, stated that he will be taking legal action against the Germany's attempt to silence critique of Israel.

© Getty Images

Critique of Israel as proxy -

While anti-Semitism remains a pressing issue in German society, it has used the critique of Israel as a proxy for the issue, which has also criminalized Jewish communities and Israelis critical of the Israeli government’s policies.

© Getty Images

Criminalizes people from MENA -

Although the newest resolution is non-binding, it influences both criminal and immigration law and creates blanketed racism toward people from the Middle East and North Africa, all while failing to confront its domestic right-wing movement.

Sources: (DW) (Human Rights Watch) (Haaretz) (CNN) (Al Jazeera)

See also: What's left of Gaza? Mapping destruction one year into the ongoing war

© Getty Images